Top Islamic Websites

Did prophet Muhammed forgive the woman who refused to convert to Islam?

Islamic history tells that when prophet Muahmemd conquered Mecca, he gave his companions a list of 10 names for persons whom should be killed wherever they were found, even if they were inside the Ka'aba (the most holy place for Msulims). Among those people who should be KILLED was a woman with the name of Sara. The reason prophet Muhammed killed her was because she went to him once asking for some charity because she was broke, and prophet Muhammed gave her money and food on hope she might convert to Islam, but she took the money and food and returned back to her town without converting to Islam. http://sirah.al-islam.com/display.asp?f=mga1598.htm That story raises many questions: 1- Is refusing to convert to Islam should be punished by DEATH? 2- Was being a Muslim a condition to receive charity? 3- Why did prophet Muhammed violate the many Quranic verses that gave immune for people who enter the Ka'aba (the most holy place for Muslims)?

Public Comments

1. I don't know. But I do know that Mohammed's favorite wife was a Christian, and I don't think she ever converted.
2. Yikes, if you are muslim please refrain from offering me any charity, as I am unwilling to pay the price.
3. Apparently, Mohammed didn't understand the whole "giving" thing if he attached conditions to it. Kinda makes the charity thing non-existent in Islam.
4. I'm sorry you seem to be grossly mis informed and incorrect on all accounts. perhaps reading the hadiths, and the prophets biography would be of more assistance to you, and show you where you erred in question 1, 2, and 3. excellent to show interest mister. peace. George he can post any language link he wants, I don't know where you live, but here we are free to express ourselves in any language we like, don't you have that where you live, if not perhaps a velvet or coloured revolution is in order. get your basic rights back friend.
5. 1. when we look around in the world we see that they do kill those who don't convert to Muslim. That's a fact, not ancient history or some book of some false prophet but a fact. Even if you are Muslim if your not the right kind. Sunni and Shiite are killing each other that's a current fact. 2. According to the current law in Iraq to receive charity you have to be their brand of Muslim. Shiite's do not give charity to Sunni's widows. That is not ancient history but a current fact talk to the men who have served over there. We get more information from them and I know them to be truthful to me. We have been getting a very good education about Muslims. 3. Since several mosques have been blown up and the people inside killed currently they do not received immunity by being in a mosque. Some ran in there to avoid being shot thinking like you did that this would save their life. The insurgents went inside the most holy place and murdered them. so today that does not give you immunity. To answer these questions if you do not believe me read a paper or talk to someone who has been there. As to the man who said that Mohammad had a christian wife if he did it is not recorded anywhere. Except by current documents that have been proven false and it is recorded that he killed people for being Christian. Had people brutally murdered for such sins as possessing a bible.
6. dont you get it yet,this is an english only place?why do you keep posting arabic links,when you know,we all speak and read english. you want to show that you have proof of your question,when you dont
7. The web-site you have referred is opening only in Arabic. Besides may I know who told you this crap of above incidents? Asa matter of fact, never Prophet Mohammed gave orders to kill the people of other faiths, for not accepting Islam. The prophet of Islam had neighbours of other faiths & his relation with them became an example for the humanity. Its better not to whip the passions of other faiths.I want you take this advice from me. Dont waste other precious time on this unwanted and baseless issues.
8. 1- Is refusing to convert to Islam should be punished by DEATH? Answer: No, there is a Chapter in the Koran, which explains that if someone believes in a different religion leave them alone. Also as a Muslim I know we do not have missionaries and we do not force people to convert we just teach them if they like the religion we teach them more and they convert. No one is forced to believe in Islam because then that wouldn't be a religion of peace. 2- Was being a Muslim a condition to receive charity? Answer: She told the Prophet that she would convert, but betrayed her word and went back to being a dancer in her city, so she was only killed for lying the charity was a gift from the Prophet (PBUH). 3- Why did prophet Muhammad violate the many Koranic verses that gave immune for people who enter the Kaaba (the most holy place for Muslims)? He did not violate such a thing.
9. mamasqui Prophet Muhammad (Sallal La Ho Wa Alayhi Wasalam) wives were all muslim and if so many of you think that muslims kill non converts then what are you all doing here?