Top Islamic Websites

According to the Quran and Hadith, did Muhammad ever lie, rob, rape or murder?

Plese base your comments on quotes from the Quran and Hadith or other muslim texts.

Public Comments

1. There is a hadeeth that tells us Prophet Muhammad's character is based on Al-Qur'an (meaning to say that his character is very perfect). It is from Aisyah R.A, says that His characters are Al-Qur'an... So, it is so not appropriate to say that he had ever done such things. He wouldn't...
2. These accusations are only made by opponents of Islam. Even the critics of Muhammad during that time did'nt accuse him of these. They were against him only because they did'nt like people getting attracted to Islam. He attained prophethood only when he was 40 years and before that, he used to be liked very much by his people. They called him "Al-Ameen" which means the "The Faithfull". When he started to proclaim the message that there is none worthy of worship other than God these same people started opposing him.
3. He didn't do those things himself, but...
4. Of course not! How do you propose to create a religion and have followers if you don't put a positive spin on what you include in the religion? If Mohammad ever did anything negative, it would not be found in any religious text.
5. If only the true shining personality of Mohammed could be perceived by all,Moslems in particular,less wrong will be perpetrated on earth as it is now with a few of us. Please read in between the lines.Anything more explicit may leed to disaffection among some of us.